Twitter: To Follow, or Not to Follow?

18September

Twitter: To Follow, or Not to Follow?

As I was writing my last blog about Twitter etiquette, a question came up: What is the etiquette on following people? Should you follow everyone who follows you, or not?

I went on a quest to find out what the best practice regarding Followers vs. Following on Twitter. The answers, it seems, are largely unclear, but there are a lot of theories out there.
My social Network on Flickr, Facebook, Twitter and MyblogLog
Photo by luc legay

The Naysayers – Don’t Follow Everyone:

Bob Bly of www.bly.com doesn’t believe in following people just because they follow you on Twitter. Instead, he talks about a ratio that every Twitter user should employ — he calls this a Followed-to-Follow ratio. According to Bly, your F:F ratio should be 10:1, meaning 10x more people are following you than you follow. Ideally, the ratio should be as high as 100:1. His thinking is that you should be concerned about getting your ideas across, not wasting time reading what other people are posting. Read more about it here.

The Yaysayers – Follow Everyone!:

In a comment on the previous post by Bob Bly, social media extraordinaire David Meerman Scott begs to differ — here’s his reply:

Bob
Yes, social media takes time. But trying to dream up metrics like this are silly. I have 25,000 followers on Twitter. I follow back everyone who follows me who demonstrate that they are human. So my ratio sucks because I follow 22,000 people.
The key is HOW you use Twitter. I have some people who I pay close attention to. I only casually scan the full stream once or twice a day. I miss probably 98% of tweets send to me.
But I look al ALL tweets that mention me @dmscott. And I look at all my DMs … I don’t think your metric is helpful.
David

His point of view, then, is that social media is about being social – it’s about making as many connections with as many people as you can. It’s no wonder he thinks this too – he often writes about the boons of Twitter on his blog, like this post on how one tweet led to him spending a week in Australia.

Likewise, Robert Scoble of Scobleizer claims he follows every person that follows him (In fact, this is the post that got us wondering the best practice for following on Twitter). Why, you ask? Well, he says it’s “Cause I believe that anyone who follows me is a friend and is someone I should listen to.” Point taken.

Oh, but wait. Scoble actually has two Twitter accounts: @notsecretscoble, where he seems to follow most of his followers, and @scobleizer, which has a lot more followers. Some of his posts on @notsecretscoble seem to suggest that following EVERYONE isn’t such a great idea, like this one posted on July 28th:

“I’ve noticed something: the best Twitterers follow fewer than 2,000 people. So do I here and I’m having a lot more fun now!”

Looks like Scoble may be switching sides.

The Middle-of-the-Roaders – Follow Only Quality Twitterers:

This post at socialmediatoday.com says you can do it either way you want – but if you’re more selective and only follow “quality” Twitterers (those that are interested in what you’re saying, not robots or spammers or celebrities), you’ll have much greater success.

So, did you follow all of that? I put together a chart of each blogger’s Twitter stats just to see if they practiced what they preach. Looks like everyone checks out according to their own personal philosophies:

twittertable1234

I can see the advantages to each Twitter philosophy. My best advice? Go with whatever works best for you – be more selective if you like, or just go for the gold and follow a lot of people to get the word out about your idea/business/product!

Now I’m curious – what do you guys think? Let me know which approach you use on your own Twitter accounts and how that approach is working out for you.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
Posted by Michelle  Posted on 18 Sep 
  • david meerman scott, following on Twitter, how many people should you follow on Twitter, Online Communities, Robert Scoble, Social Media, Social network, Twitter
  • Post Comments 8

    Posted by ContentScoop on
    • Sep 20 2009
    Reply  
    I am quite new to twitter. I usually follow people whom I can identify with, meaning writers, cartoonists, etc. Now, I love to read about blogging; so I follow people who are expert bloggers. Every once in a while, I will be kind to people who follow me and will follow them out of gratitude.
    Posted by Wintress on
    • Sep 20 2009
    Reply  
    Hey @ContentScoop. Thanks for reading (and commenting!) I sort of follow the same strategy. I follow clients, so I can try to connect with them and stay on their radar. I follow people in the marketing or writing industries that I think have interesting things to say. And, sometimes, I follow people just cause the whim takes me. I don't follow people who look spammy or who tweet too much -- if I get someone who is constantly taking up my twitter stream, I can't see what everyone else is saying!
    Posted by Andrew Zar on
    • Sep 22 2009
    Reply  
    Not that I'm a good one to proclaim knowledge on this topic - I have avoided Twitter and Facebook and MySpace and whatever else, even though I run several businesses. But I would just chime in and say that anyone you spend attention on should earn it - by peaking your interest in some way. So I would vote for middle-of-the-road; but, take that with a grain of salt given I don't have a twitter account yet. (I actually lament that I will be forced into it with my latest venture, which will rely on a different word of mouth than my up and running companies... :( But I found your post here very interesting, keep posting (you earned my following you) :)
    Posted by Wintress on
    • Sep 23 2009
    Reply  
    Thanks Andrew! Got your twitter and FB follow too. :-) You're caving in -- just like the rest of us! I fought Social Media until the bitter end. I also insisted on keeping my first cellphone until T-Mobile said it was too old to support my plan! Once you start playing with this SM stuff though, it's really addicting.
    Posted by AHCopywriter on
    • Oct 7 2009
    Reply  
    Middle of the road for me. I'll follow followers who make interesting posts, amusing tweets, share helpful links & information, or where I see the potential for mutual business benefit. I just don't have the time to scan through thousands of followers' tweets (though sadly it may be some time before @ahcopywriter achieves that level of success!). If I feel like I've been followed just to achieve a reciprocal follow, it's not going to happen...
    Posted by Wintress on
    • Oct 7 2009
    Reply  
    Hi AHCopywriter, just followed you on Twitter. And you don't even have to follow me back! :-)
    Posted by AHCopywriter on
    • Oct 14 2009
    Reply  
    Had I not already followed you though?! I'm not so much losing track as losing my mind. Help...
    Posted by Wintress on
    • Oct 15 2009
    Reply  
    Heh. I think you did actually. :-)

    Drop us a line

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *